The nature of humanity has been a subject of philosophical, theological, and scientific contemplation for centuries. Questions about the relationship between the mind, brain, and the essence of man—whether we are purely physical beings or possess a deeper spiritual dimension—have shaped much of human inquiry. At the heart of this discussion lies the question: What is the true nature of man? To answer this, we must explore the intersection of the physical (the brain), the mental (the mind), and the spiritual (the soul or spirit) in relation to the divine, considering three broad views of man: 1) man as body only, 2) man as body with a soul (spirit), and 3) man as pure spirit having a body experience.
Man as Body Only: The Materialist View
From a purely materialistic perspective, man is viewed as a complex biological organism. The brain, in this view, is the seat of consciousness, emotions, thoughts, and decision-making processes. The mind is not seen as a distinct entity but rather a byproduct of the brain’s physical functioning. This perspective aligns with modern scientific reductionism, where human experience, including consciousness, is reduced to the firing of neurons, the release of neurotransmitters, and complex biochemical reactions. According to this view, there is no “mind” beyond the brain; thought and experience are merely the result of physical processes.
This perspective is rooted in a purely empirical worldview, where all phenomena, including consciousness, must be explained through observable, physical mechanisms. The mind, in this context, is no more than a collection of chemical and electrical interactions. This model aligns with the findings of neuroscience, which links thoughts, memories, and feelings directly to brain activity, and suggests that the human experience can ultimately be understood as a product of evolution and biological processes.
Yet, despite its explanatory power, this view leaves much unanswered. The mind, even in its most advanced scientific understandings, remains inexplicably linked to subjective experiences, emotions, and consciousness—the “qualia” of existence. The mind-body problem, as articulated by philosophers such as David Chalmers, reveals that while the brain can be studied physically, the subjective experience of being aware remains elusive. The materialist perspective, while compelling in its simplicity, does not fully explain why or how consciousness arises, nor why human beings experience moral agency, creativity, and self-awareness.
Man as a Body with a Soul: The Dualistic View
In contrast, many theological and philosophical traditions assert that man is not merely physical but also spiritual in nature. The second view, that man is a body with a soul, allows for a dualistic understanding of human existence. According to this view, the body is the physical vessel, but the soul or spirit is the true essence of a person. The brain remains essential for interaction with the material world, but the mind or consciousness is seen as transcendent, not reducible to brain activity alone.
This dualism echoes philosophical traditions such as René Descartes’ mind-body dualism, where the mind (or soul) is a non-physical entity, distinct from the body but able to interact with it. In this view, the mind is not merely an illusion but a real, immaterial aspect of human experience that is linked to the body through the brain. The concept of the soul, present in many religious and spiritual traditions, suggests that human beings have an essence that exists beyond the material world and persists beyond physical death.
Christianity, for example, speaks of humans being created in God’s image, where the “image” refers not to physical appearance but to the capacity for reason, love, and moral judgment. Genesis 1:26—“Let us make man in our image, after our likeness”—implies that humanity shares a divine essence that allows for spiritual awareness and communion with God. Similarly, the Quran describes human beings as being endowed with a soul that is breathed into them by God, making them unique among creation.
This dualistic view is also found in Eastern philosophies like Hinduism and Buddhism, where the true nature of human beings is considered to be spiritual, and the body is a temporary vessel. The Bhagavad Gita, for instance, teaches that the soul (Atman) is eternal, unchanging, and distinct from the physical body, which is subject to birth, decay, and death.
In this view, the soul or spirit is the seat of human consciousness, purpose, and identity, and the body is simply a temporary vehicle through which the spirit interacts with the material world. The mind, in this model, is shaped by both the spiritual essence and the physical body, giving rise to an integrated self that reflects both the material and the immaterial.
Man as Pure Spirit Having a Body Experience: The Spiritual Perspective
The third view posits that man is fundamentally spirit, and the body is simply a temporary vessel through which the spirit experiences the physical world. This perspective places the spirit at the core of human identity, with the physical body serving as a transient means to interact with material reality. From this standpoint, the physical body and brain are seen as tools for the soul to navigate and experience the physical world, but they are not the essence of who we truly are.
This view is rooted in mystical and spiritual traditions that emphasize the eternal and transcendent nature of the human spirit. In Christian mysticism, for example, the soul is understood as the true self, and the body is merely a passing phase in the soul’s journey. Similarly, Eastern spirituality, particularly in Hinduism and Buddhism, teaches that the soul or consciousness (Atman) is the true reality, and the physical world is an illusion (Maya) through which the spirit passes. Ralph Waldo Emerson and Eckhart Tolle both advocate for the idea that human beings are pure consciousness or spirit, temporarily inhabiting physical forms.
This view aligns with quantum physics, where the observer plays a fundamental role in the creation of reality. David Bohm and Max Planck suggested that consciousness is not merely a byproduct of the brain but an integral aspect of the universe itself. If consciousness is an intrinsic part of reality, as some quantum physicists and mystics propose, then it stands to reason that man’s true nature is spiritual, and the body is merely a temporary expression of that spiritual essence.
Bridging the Divide: A Holistic Understanding
The most compelling perspective, when synthesizing these views, is that man is a body with a spirit or soul. This integrated view allows us to appreciate both the material and immaterial aspects of human existence. The brain, as the physical organ, is essential for interacting with the world, but the mind, which includes consciousness, reason, and emotion, transcends mere biological processes. Our spiritual essence—the soul or spirit—gives us the capacity for self-awareness, morality, creativity, and transcendence.
The ongoing debate between the materialistic view and spiritual perspectives is not one of stark opposition, but one of complementarity. We cannot ignore the physical realities of the brain, which is essential for cognition and interaction with the world. However, by recognizing the spirit as the true essence of who we are, we allow for a deeper understanding of the mind and consciousness, one that is not solely reducible to material causes. This holistic approach resonates with both ancient wisdom and modern scientific inquiries, acknowledging that human existence is far more complex than a mere interaction of physical processes.
Conclusion: The Divine Connection
Ultimately, the question of what man truly is—body, soul, or spirit—is intricately tied to our understanding of the divine. Whether seen through the lens of materialism, dualism, or spiritualism, each view offers unique insights into human nature. The most logical, perhaps, is the understanding of man as both body and spirit—a being created in the image of the divine, with the physical body serving as a tool for the spiritual journey. This view allows for a profound connection between humanity and the divine, and for a richer understanding of the mind, the brain, and the very essence of who we are.
It should be evident that the way we live and experience our lives is totally dependent on our beliefs at any given time. In a follow-up essay, I will reflect on the process of changing our minds.
What is your view? I would love to hear from you.
If you like articles and books of a spiritual nature, we have lots to offer. I have dozens of essays and am continually adding more. We also have an entire series of books on spirituality available on our website (dinojamesbooks.com).
We love engaging with our readers. For more information contact Robert@dinojamesbooks.com.
